Latest Headlines
Court Case Reveals Alice Walton’s Contributions to Crystal Bridges
A tumultuous lawsuit between Fisk University and the State of Tennessee has revealed just how much money Alice Walton has donated to her pet project, the Crystal Bridges Art Museum in Benton County, Arkansas. The figure is an astounding $317 million, small change for a woman worth $19 billion, but a bonafide fortune for any working American. The Walton family has long been a prominent patron of art and entertainment in northwest Arkansas - the Bud Walton Arena at the University of Arkansas is just a stone’s throw away from the Walton Arts Center in downtown Fayetteville. So Alice’s contributions to a still-unconstructed art museum in the area are part of a long family tradition.
That family tradition exists for a reason: in the span of six months - from November 2007 to June 2008 - the Walton family made $29 billion off the increase in Wal-Mart’s stock price. With income like that, it’s not surprising that family members can afford to build art museums almost single-handedly. Meanwhile, Wal-Mart employees across the country continue to make poverty-level wages and go without decent, affordable health care.
The article quotes museum director Bob Workman saying, “Crystal Bridges is a gift to the community from Alice Walton and the Walton family. The focus is on what we are creating, not what it is costing.” Perhaps an even better gift to the community - and communities across the country - would be to pay the Wal-Mart’s 1.4 million U.S. workers a fair wage, and build wealth from the ground up.
Crystal Bridges case sheds light on contributions [Arkansas Democrat-Gazette]
Alice Walton, her family and one of their foundations have donated $317 million to the Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art, which has nearly half a billion dollars in assets, according to documents filed in a Tennessee court.
Fisk University in Nashville included the information in a brief appealing a lower court’s decision to bar a $30 million deal between the university and Crystal Bridges that would have split ownership of the Alfred Stieglitz Collection between the university and the Bentonville museum.
Walton, the Wal-Mart heiress, announced her plans in 2005 to build the museum near Central Avenue and J Street at an estimated cost of $50 million. Officials have been tight-lipped about funding since. Construction continues on the building, scheduled to open in 2010.
Museum Executive Director Bob Workman said late last year that plans for the museum had grown, but would not disclose how much more it would cost.
The Fisk brief reveals that $138 million of the museum’s $488 million in assets are “liquid.” The information was attributed to an undated deposition from Workman.
Beyond the Walton funding, it’s unclear where the remaining $171 million in assets originated.
Workman declined to elaborate on the deposition last week.
“At this time, we are not sharing our project costs or any details about project assets,” Workman wrote in an e-mail. “Crystal Bridges is a gift to the community from Alice Walton and the Walton family. The focus is on what we are creating, not what it is costing.”
The O’Keeffe Museum has until Sept. 7 to file a brief in the appellate court and a judge will be assigned to the case after Fisk submits a response brief, due 14days later.
Walton, her two brothers and sister-in-law are each worth an estimated $16 billion according to Forbes.com.
Crystal Bridges reportedlyspent $35 million on the painting Kindred Spirits in 2005 and was a joint partner with the National Gallery of Art on a $68 million offer for Thomas Eakins’ The Gross Clinic in 2006. The Eakins offer was matched and awarded to a collaboration of groups in Philadelphia.
Months later, Crystal Bridges announced it purchased Eakins’ portrait of professor Benjamin H. Rand for an undisclosed amount.
Last November, Walton and other museum officials attended an American painting and sculpture auction at Sotheby’s in New York City where some works sold for several million dollars, but there was no word of any items purchased by Crystal Bridges.
The museum is expected to include space for between 200 and 300 pieces. Only a handful of paintings and a rare book are known to be included in the collection.
The museum, designed by renowned architect Moshe Safdie, is scheduled to include 100,000 square feet of gallery space, a library, 250-seat auditorium and a sculpture garden.
In 1949, American painter Georgia O’Keeffe donated the Stieglitz Collection to historically black Fisk University. It contains works by her and her husband - the late photographer Alfred Stieglitz - and other artists.
Court approval is necessary because Fisk is trying to change the parameters of the gift, which stipulated the collection remain intact, on display and never sold.
The agreement is opposed by the Georgia O’Keeffe Museum in Santa Fe, N.M., which argues it is the successor to the late painter’s estate.
A judge had rejected an agreement with Fisk and the New Mexico museum earlier in 2007 that would have allowed the museum to buy just the collection’s premier painting - O’Keeffe’s Radiator Building - Night, New York - for $7.5 million.
The judge cited the $30 million offer from Crystal Bridges as a reason why she declined the agreement.
Posted by Alex Goldschmidt on Wednesday, August 27, 2008
Click Here for a Printer-Friendly Version
SEARCH WAL-MART WATCH
Most Popular Tags
apparel battlefield benefits brookins chicago city council clips competition competitors congress daily daily clips debate development doctor employees expansion exploitation factories government health care healthcare hearing imports influence insurance international jobs labor legislation lobbying mandate new news obama pakistan politics products residents safety senate sourcing target union wages wall street journal washington wildernessTop Posts
- Happy 4th of July, From Your Friends at Wal-Mart Watch
- Today’s Final Word on Health Care
- Wall Street Journal Takes Wal-Mart to the Woodshed
- Wal-Mart: Sticks and Stones May Break Our Bones, But Health Care Could Kill Our Rivals
- Ald. Brookins Won’t Give Up on Second Wal-Mart Store, Ups Pressure on City Council
- Final Hearing Date Set in Wilderness Standoff
- Wal-Mart Watch Daily Clips- July 1st 2009
- Wal-Mart, U.S. Chamber Oppose Labor Rules in Pakistan and Afghanistan
- Workers Speak Out: Despite Calls for Reform, Wal-Mart Still Shortchanging Workers on Health Care
- Wal-Mart Says: ‘Hasta La Vista’ Union Supporters
Archive
Subscribe to this blog
Subscribe to the Wal-Mart Watch RSS Feed
![]()







View Wal-Mart Watch's videos on YouTube
Contact Us
Have a tip? Contact us.









COMMENTS
NEW YORK (CNNMoney.com)—As things in the economy have gotten worse, the number of people and businesses heading to bankruptcy court has spiked.
Bankruptcy filings surged 29% in the 12 months that ended June 30, according to government figures released Wednesday.
Total filings rose to 967,831 from 751,056 a year earlier.
Business filings jumped more than 41% to 33,822 from 23,889 in the year-ago period. Personal filings totaled 934,009, up 28% from last year.
“As we continue to hear more bad economic news, we will continue to see bankruptcies spiral upwards,” said Jack Williams, resident scholar at the American Bankruptcy Institute.
The bankruptcy group expects filings to reach 1.2 million this year, as problems in the housing market have “reverberated throughout the economy,” he added.
The data also showed that filings for Chapter 7 rose 36% to 615,748 in the 12 months that ended June 30.
Chapter 7 bankruptcy is designed to give individual debtors a “fresh start” by discharging many of their debts. Under Chapter 7 a filer’s assets minus those exempted by his home state are liquidated and given to creditors first in line for repayment, while the rest of his debts are cancelled.
Another type of individual bankruptcy - Chapter 13 - requires debtors to pay back their debts over time. Total Chapter 13 filings rose 17% to 344,421 from 294,693 a year earlier.
Filings for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, which is aimed at assisting struggling corporations or partnerships, rose more than 30% to 7,293.
Bobby in New York, Kentucky, Los Angeles
Wednesday, August 27 at 04:40 PM
Wow, a person uses their money to build an art museum and somehow that is ‘evil’ and that money should have been given as raises to Wal-Mart employees!! Wonder if Warren Buffett or Bill Gates, was using their money to build an art museum, if there would be an outcry by the unions, for them to give their money to Berkshire’s or Microsoft’s employees!! After all, didn’t they too, make their money off the sweat of workers?
Besides, I think the IRS, might have a problem with stockholders giving their personal money directly to a corporation’s workers as raises!!
“the Walton family made $29 billion off the increase in Wal-Mart’s stock price.”
What does that have to do with anything, apparently that means the stock price has gone UP, so ALL of Wal-Mart’s stockholders made money!! Should ALL of the stockholders give raises to Wal-Mart’s employees too?
Another clear attempt at ‘class warfare’!!
RDS in
Wednesday, August 27 at 10:39 PM
Geoffrey Joffrey’s Palace
(please forgive me - I’m writing and typing it as i go; and no luxury the pencil).
Mrs. Hilton - “You girls call me later.”.
Nicki was holding the door;
She took at her phone and glanced back; (3 feet to go); checked her speed dial (number 1);
And pressed.
She loved Los Angeles; walking into the sunshine;
She looked to her left; the police car was still there;
But she stopped.
She saw the cop leaning against the car; rubbing his eyes underneath his sunglasses. He was kinda slumping ........
“Yeah - but have seen this?”.
She looked over.
It was this ten year-old Chineese boy;
He kinda bent his knees - his arms straight out; with fists.
And then he started rotating his arms.
She’d lived in Los Angeles a long-time - seeing alot of things; so she ignored and looked at her phone. Her new driver held the door open; and she spoke to the cop;
She gave him the thumbs-up; all is well - “thanks.”.
The cop saw it;
And so did Chow Lee.
Chow Lee’s eyes lit up;
He turned slightly - he had a new audience; but didn’t want to lose his old-one; Mrs. Hilton kinda smiled; and then he really started gyrating.
Yet she smiled before she got in the car.
The new driver closed the door; and got in.
She rested her elbow on the arm-rest; and asked him.
“Do you have any children?”.
..
“Not yet maam.”.
..
“Well don’t.”.
..
She was rubbing her eyes now ...............
What’s up with that freakin Chineese Kid?”.
..............
Ah, he . ..............
:).
Anonymous in usa.com
Wednesday, August 27 at 11:22 PM
Now I’m going to write a commercial.
Three Characters - The Walmart Debit Card.
“It’s loadable;
It’s a savings account -
..............
Use it Wherever You Go!.”.;
And then a voice; kinda like the movie guy;
“The Walmart Debit Card -
............
Apply Now and We’ll Add $20 to your $100 Balance.”.
............
And then the ending of Bill O’Reilly’s Old Program comes on;
..............
The ending to “Inside Edition;”.
:).
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 12:10 AM
Monday, May 23, 2005
Washington, D.C., May 23, 2005 – Today, one of the world’s wealthiest women, Wal-Mart heiress Alice Walton, unveiled plans for the new Walton museum Crystal Bridges. The Bentonville, Arkansas museum will display Walton’s newly purchased painting “Kindred Spirits” by Asher B. Durand, which she bought for a record $35 million. But amid growing concerns about Wal-Mart’s corporate ethics lurks a question about how, yet again, the Walton family may be using their jaw-dropping wealth to arrange sweetheart deals that benefit them and leave out others. Wal-Mart Watch today calls upon Alice Walton to admit if she used a new Arkansas bill to avoid paying the requisite 6 percent sales tax for her acquisition, leaving Arkansans to lose out on the revenue.
The Background Behind Alice Walton’s Possible Multi-Million Dollar Sweetheart Deal
New Walton Painting Could Generate $3 Million in State and Local Taxes. According to the Arkansas Times, the $35 million spent by Alice Walton to purchase “Kindred Spirits” by Asher Durand could generate state and local sales tax of some $3 million. And the New York State Department of Taxation & Finance reports that, REGARDLESS of the location of the purchase, the state where an owner takes physical possession of a painting – in this case, presumably Arkansas – is the STATE in which the SALES TAX WOULD apply. [Arkansas Times, 5/19/05; New York State Department of Taxation & Finance, phone report, 5/23/05]
WITHOUT Special Exemption, State Law MANDATES Sales Tax on Art. Tim Leathers, the Arkansas revenue commissioner, said ALL the state’s museums, like other nonprofits, are subject to sales tax on items they purchase. Even if they buy them in a state that exempts art from sales tax, they STILL have to pay the tax in Arkansas, he said. [Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, 3/16/05]
BUT New Arkansas Legislation Exempts Walton Museum from Sales Tax. “An ACT passed this year by the Arkansas Legislature helped solidify plans for the new Walton museum. Arkansas Act 1865, sponsored by Rep. Horace Hardwick, R-Bentonville, provides SALES AND USE TAX EXEMPTIONS to nonprofit museums for the building construction and art purchases. To qualify, the museum MUST open to the public before Jan. 1, 2013, cost more than $30 million to build and house more than $100 million worth of art.” The Walton Foundation museum is scheduled to open May 2009. [Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, 5/20/05]
Walton Family Widely Considered To Be Behind Exemption Legislation. Alice Walton and the Foundation LOBBIED for passage of a BILL that EXEMPTS the Foundation from having to pay Arkansas’ 6 percent sales tax on the acquisition or sale of artwork. [Bill sponsor Rep. Horace] Hardwick wouldn’t identify the nonprofit organization mentioned in the bill, but sources who requested anonymity told the Northwest Arkansas Business Journal that it’s the Walton Foundation and that Alice Walton, daughter of Wal-Mart founder Sam Walton, was behind the museum plan. [Arkansas Business, 5/19/05; 3/14/05]
Special Treatment: Little Rock Arts Center Not Eligible for Walton Exemption. “The [sales tax exemption] law didn’t exempt the Walton museum by name, but was written in such a way to apply to it and no other.” For example, the Arkansas Arts Center in Little Rock has to PAY sales tax on its acquisitions, and is NOT eligible for the exemption, because the legislation passed this year it only applies to museums opened between Jan. 1, 2005, and Jan. 1, 2013. [Arkansas Times, 5/19/05; Arkansas Business, 3/14/05]
Tax Law Secrecy Masks Tax Payments, But Waltons Could Choose to Disclose. The Arkansas Times reported, “Because of tax law secrecy, it’s likely Arkansans WILL NEVER KNOW IF [Alice Walton’s $35M purchase of the Durand] painting was taxed or even if an effort was made to collect the tax. The Waltons could say if they chose.” [Arkansas Times, 5/19/05, emphasis added] ~~~~~~~~WMW~~~~
ddrb in
Thursday, August 28 at 12:13 AM
The Fisk brief reveals that $138 million of the museum’s $488 million in assets are “liquid.” The information was attributed to an undated deposition from Workman.
Beyond the Walton funding, it’s unclear where the remaining $171 million in assets originated.
Workman declined to elaborate on the deposition last week.
“At this time, we are not sharing our project costs or any details about project assets,” Workman wrote in an e-mail. “Crystal Bridges is a gift to the community from Alice Walton and the Walton family. The focus is on what we are creating, not what it is costing.” ~Arkansas Democrat Gazette~~~~Note: Since when is cost not THE object to a Walton? Maybe when the citizens of Arkanas are picking up the tax tab,courtesy of specially tailored legislation to provide tax exemption for the construction of ,aaand art acquisitions for, the Crystal Bridges Museum.
ddrb in
Thursday, August 28 at 12:22 AM
And a few words about the income of NW Arkansans:~~~~~~~~~According to data released by the U.S. Census Bureau today, Northwest Arkansas had a median household income of $44,552 in 2007, below the national median of $48,934, even with a whole nest of billionaires in Benton County and assorted NWA multi-millionaires to pump up the averages.
At the same time, Northwest Arkansas’ poverty rate was 15.2% or about 64,000 people living below the poverty level. That is above the state’s rate of 15.1% and the national poverty rate of 12.1%.
The data also show 17.5% of Arkansawyers don’t have health care coverage, well above the national average is 15.4%.
Why do you think that is?
Another news story today brought home the growing income disparity in our state. The Arkansas Department of Higher Education released revised figures yesterday ranking the salaries of higher education administrators. Here’s the latest list:
1. UA System President, $538,722
2. UA Medical Sciences Chancellor, $530,786
3. University of Central Arkansas President, $508,540
4. Arkansas State University System President, $464,980
5. UA Fayetteville Chancellor, $363,446
A single mom, with two kids, working as a Data Entry Specialist makes $16,283, which is below the federal poverty line. Minimum wage workers make even less, $13,208.
What are the Chamber of Cowbirds and the Fayetteville Economic Development Council doing to create jobs that pay a living wage? What will the Mayor’s $150,000 consultant’s report do to help working families? Probably not much, because low wage workers and unemployed residents are not among the “stakeholders” they will be interviewing. They will be talking to the Northwest Arkansas Council of Corporations and Wealthy Business Executives. The Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families offers five good suggestions that the state legislature could adopt to make a difference, but tax and appropriation bills require a 3/4 vote to pass. None of them will pass, because the Chamber and the Farm Bureau will oppose them, and the Republicans will not vote for them.” The Iconoclast"~~~~~~~~Gee, that’s funny,they passed a legislation to exempt taxes for Alice’s Crystal Bridges museum. But just how will that museum help people save money and live better?
ddrb in
Thursday, August 28 at 01:47 AM
Mrs. Hilton had driven away;
The cop said goodbye to Chow Lee;
Paris had set-up her next appointment with Geoffrey.
..........
Chow Lee went to say hello to his friend Geoffrey;
Nick and Paris were just walking out the door;
With a pink dog; gold chain; gold teeth; happy and clueless.
Chow Lee just about got to the door;
And stopped dead in his tracks;
Dumfounded - jaw opened.
..................
“What The Hell Is That?”.
..................
Paris was beaming -
......................
“Kid - That’s Nibblets.”.
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 01:58 AM
The end.
:).
Thank you for your’ patience.
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 02:04 AM
Wow, a person uses their money to build an art museum and somehow that is ‘evil’ and that money should have been given as raises to Wal-Mart employees!!
In other words, let them eat cake!
Thank you for your’ patience.
Sorry, Anonymous, but my patience ran out long ago. Your scroll-wheel poetry takes up too much white.
There is more to life than “cheap underwear“. ~ The Peninsula Neighborhood Association
Ken V in Texas
Thursday, August 28 at 05:13 AM
Anonymous in usa.com is just an arm of Wal-mart union busting team, trying to pretend there is spam on this website.
Johnny be good. in
Thursday, August 28 at 05:39 AM
big goddam deal ken who cares about this shit anyway?picking at straws wmw and more bs on here as usual
MATT IN in gresham,oregon
Thursday, August 28 at 06:01 AM
Wal*Mart is Selling Toxic toys and Deadly Bassinets…
Keep Laughing Alice…
Take a cue from Warren Buffit and give all your money away. I’m sure Onward Christian Soldiers would concur. Right OCS?
Bobby in New York, Kentucky, Los Angeles
Thursday, August 28 at 11:06 AM
BTW: The Republican Convention next week will be sponsored ,in great part, by EXXON-MOBIL. Who’d uh thunk it?
ddrb in
Thursday, August 28 at 11:17 AM
Doesn’t Don Imus remind you of the Crypt Keeper in a cowboy hat? He and John McSame are a matched pair of creaky relics.
What a drag it is getting old! ~ Mick Jagger
Ken V in Texas
Thursday, August 28 at 12:07 PM
Ken V; Is that why I always think of fossil fuels when I look at these two old Repub fossils? If you want the trifecta of tombtenders, FYIl,lots of bloggers refer to Cindy as being reminiscent of the Cryptkeeper,too.
ddrb in
Thursday, August 28 at 12:58 PM
If You’re Talking “Tombtenders” Here...
I nominate Rush Limbaugh. That fat, little, drug-crazed, talking head had the nerve to make the remark that if you take away Barack Obama’s teleprompter, he’d be nothing.
Take away Limbaugh’s microphone and he’s just another fat, little, drug-crazed, Republican Right Wing Nut.
ScrewedbyWalMart in Anytown, America
Thursday, August 28 at 04:43 PM
Be careful - the dreams - the predictions.
“ ..........
So these three storms; central in the gulf - become 1.”.
One storm - deciding -
Yet the patter is full - from the Western Coast (Africa);
...............
So they sit - so they linger -
Gathering strength -
With noplace to go -
................
?.
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 05:45 PM
“And once; only;
I saw his grave.”.
My father ... a union man;
And his father.
Both died.
And I prayed them (for even today - still - i a m poor).
With words deeds and paper.
What left to prove - Sir.?.
That’s a simple question;
For I have loved - and been loved.
I thought god a great man;
knowing everything -
When invented -
Both man and woman.
Will you sell your’ horse .......................
So I can fade away.
I shit you not.
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 05:49 PM
This one’s for you Ken - Ken from Texas.
It’s “Desert Storm.”.
A western.
...............
He had a 10 gallon (pay close attention Ken); bought and paid for.
...............
He pretended alot things; dreamed alot.
..............
He took his 10 gallon hat;
His newbought horse;
..................
And discovered ................
Suddenly ....
Life was the dream.
..................
Read it ten times .............
It’s a compliment.
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 05:59 PM
“You hold em;
(I was young);
He handed me wrench -
He was on his way -
A union man.
To Indianopolis.
He was tired -
I was young.
That’s the last time i saw my father;
A union man;
before he died;
In indianoplis.
:).
Forgive me - i was only 2.
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 06:06 PM
And second;
Again this simple question;
For lightning and thunder -
All around me.
(you think i’m kidiing);
..........
:).
..................
Wanna trade paychecks.
For suddenly the thunder has stopped.
Only lightning now.
...................
I shit you not -
You in the eye of the hurricane.
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 06:18 PM
(no father - ............ why);
You better go outside your house;
Smoke a cigarrette if inclined.
.....................
.........................
Anonymous in usa.com
Thursday, August 28 at 06:21 PM
Anonymous in usa.com
Horrible, yet compelling.
Like a bad accident between a car full of kids and a Wal*Mart Semi. The line of cars rubbernecking. Nobody stopping to see if they can help because they are all running late for something important. You want to look away but can’t, and there doesn’t seem to be an off switch. It must be here someplace*
* brought to you by the letter “Bb” so sue me!
Bobby in New York, Kentucky, Los Angeles
Thursday, August 28 at 08:00 PM
Take a close look at the pic of Alice Walton and then take a look at this:
http://thewizardofoz.warnerbros.com/movie/img/photos/photo5.jpg
“I’ll get you, my little pretty ............. and your little dog too!”
Harness the infinite power of coincidence. Deepak Chopra
Ken V in Texas
Saturday, August 30 at 10:13 AM
Comment Policy
WalmartWatch.com reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to remove or refuse to post blog comments.