Friday Blog Round-Up: Human Rights and Superconsumers


It’s Cyber Monday Week! But don’t think there’s not a whole lot else going on in the world of Wal-Mart.

SUSTAINABILITY AND MASS RETAILING ARE MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE
Wal-Mart kicked off the orgy of overconsumption and frivolity that IS the holiday shopping season with Black Friday last week. The company is hoping the Baccanalian riot will continue all the way to Christmas eve. How does the company manage to simultaneously promote rampant consumerism AND claim to be environmentally-friendly? We’re mildly astounded.

A Holiday Message [Marc Gunther, Huffington Post]

Yes, ‘tis the season when millions of Americans work themselves into a frenzy by buying things for others (and themselves) that they don’t need with money they don’t have. In a down economy.

It’s a stark reminder that the road to sustainability will be a long and difficult one and that corporate America, without environmental activism and dramatic changes in consumer behavior, won’t get us there anytime soon.

Wal-Mart, desperate for a good holiday shopping season, is keeping its Canadian stores open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, like it does with many of its US-based stores. While this may or may not help its business, Wal-Mart’s actions are almost certainly hurting the environment. From Writing on the Wal:

Here’s an example of how Wal-Mart’s sustainability crusade jumps the tracks. Keeping those 80 stores open 24 hours a day means higher energy use during decidedly off-peak shopper hours. It also means that employees are going to be driving their cars more to staff the extra hours. The result is a larger carbon footprint for Wal-Mart.

And despite all the dispute over whether Wal-Mart’s green initiatives are for real (we’re not exactly convinced over here, and many people raise excellent points about the inherent unsustainability of Wal-Mart’s business model) Clean Break does raise a hopeful point:

The fact is there’s a competition going on amongst major retailers in North America who want to be perceived as the greenest of them all. They see this as a way to gain a competitive advantage and at the same time lower costs, and perhaps just as important, they see they have no option if they want to stay relevant in a market where green-minded consumers are demanding more. This is all a very good thing.

While others, no matter how much good the company does, won’t forget Wal-Mart’s past sins:

Wal-Mart: Putting The “Light” In Enlightenment [Ecorazzi]

Wal-Mart could plant 5 billion trees, invent a magic car that runs only on positive thoughts and strap Dick Cheney on a spaceship to the moon and I STILL wouldn’t touch those corndogs!

After the jump, Human Rights Campaign, toxic toys and superconsumers.

HUMAN RIGHTS CAMPAIGN: “NO WAL-MART PRODUCTS FOR THE HOLIDAYS, PLEASE”
Wal-mart has the ignonimous honor of being the company to make the biggest fall on HRC’s workplace rights list. The company’s score fell from 65 to 40, warranting a call to the gay community not to shop at the store. What if other groups who the company discriminates against stopped shopping there? Like, the differently-abled, non-white people and women? Like the old saying goes, you catch more shareholders with honey than with vinegar.

Gay Rights Group Rates Wal-Mart “Do Not Buy” [Andrea Stone, Huffington Post]

The Human Rights Campaign, the nation’s largest gay rights group, is giving Wal-Mart (WMT) a red “do not buy” rating in its new consumer guide, bestowing a lump of coal on the retail giant just in time for the holiday shopping season.

HRC up against a ‘Wal’ [Good As You]

What a difference a year makes....[N]ow, the day before Turkey Day ‘07, the Human Rights Campaign has admonished the Arkansas-based retailer for what it considers to be a gay rights capitulation brought about by the other side’s boycott threats. Saying Wal-Mart is “moving in reverse on equal treatment of their employees and their gay and lesbian consumers,” the nation’s largest gay rights organization has given the retail giant a low score of 40 in this years “Buying For Equality” guide.

Shopping? Consider Buying for Equality [Minnesota Monitor]

Corporations have become one of the few spaces in America where lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people find equality. Domestic partner benefits, transgender inclusive health plans and nondiscrimination policies in corporate America far surpass anything LGBT people can get from their government. The Human Rights Campaign has created the Buying Guide for Equality.  The top Minnesota companies to shop include Target, Best Buy, General Mills, Ameriprise, SuperValu and US Bank...HRC has not called for a boycott of Wal-Mart but instead urged supporters to “shop elsewhere” at retailers with higher LGBT support such as Target.

BUT THAT’S NOT THE ONLY REASON NOT TO SHOP AT WAL-MART

Five Reasons You Should NOT shop at Wal-Mart [Damali Ayo]

With the holiday season approaching, I find it helpful to remind us all why we should buy local and perhaps pay a bit more for a quality product instead of heading for the cheap. Wal-Mart has a bad track record on just about every area of evaluation. I’ve listed five things in order of how strongly i feel about each reason. ...
1. Wal-Mart exploits poor people at every junction of its business. It relies on keeping them poor for their profit.

TOXIC TOYS CONTINUE TO WORRY CONSUMERS
This video is awesome for several reasons. 1. It manages to use STDs in a humorous context. 2. Pick-Up Line Barbie was always our favorite. 3. Campaign for America’s Future has managed to address a serious subject without taking itself too seriously, no easy task.

Toxic Toys in Santa’s Sled? Women of Steel Take Action [Firedoglake]

The United Steelworkers (USW) union, like the rest of us, is outraged over the flood of toxic toys. But unlike the Bush administration and its disaster of a Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) chairwoman, Nancy Nord, the 850,000-member union has launched a campaign that enables members to take action to protect their children—and at the same time, see the connections between the nation’s unfettered trade and failed regulatory policies and the consequences in the crib and playpen.

Children Made Ill from China-made Toy [John Birch Society]

The Chinese factory had intentionally substituted a cheaper but highly toxic chemical for a safer ingredient. And it’s not the first time. Similar recent substitutions included antifreeze in toothpaste and formaldehyde in some foodstuffs. One Chinese manufacturer stated that it is not uncommon for toy companies to use toxic chemicals in place of safer alternatives: “It’s always used in undetectable parts on a toy to avoid inspection. Plus, after painting, it’s even harder to discover the problem.”

Wal-Mart critics begin highlighting product safety issues [BloggingStocks]

Product safety has been in the spotlight this year as recalls involving toothpaste, toys, food items and more have been in the news.. Most of these recalls stem from poor product quality control and Chinese exporters who are apparently cutting safety corners. Consumers, though, connect product quality to retailers—not manufacturers.

It looks like lead isn’t the only thing parents have to worry about. What happened to that Toy Safety Net that’s supposed to protect consumers from imminent death?

BUILDING SUPERCONSUMERS

Consumer-Driven Culture Is Killing Our Democracy [AlterNet]

Don’t expect Wal-Mart to suddenly become more moral. Wal-Mart is a piece of paper, it’s a contract. Wal-Mart has consumers who love the good deals they can get, and it has investors who want the highest possible return. Wal-Mart is not going to do anything that hurts its bottom line.

Posted by Alex Goldschmidt on Friday, November 30, 2007

COMMENTS

Seems that going after Wal-Mart wasn’t enough.......now, it’s Tesco’s turn to face the wrath of the mighty union.

From FT.com in
Friday, November 30 at 10:28 PM

lookin for my main man matt.you all see him cause i want to learn about being about.wonder if he price’in and countin at the local ufcw grocer or target or any of them high priced china shops when you can get that china crap at your fn local walmart.matt you need to come into the radar and we can both light up the screen.missing you.

student of matthew vantress in gresham oregon
Saturday, December 01 at 09:41 PM

..HRC has not called for a boycott of Wal-Mart but instead urged supporters to “shop elsewhere”...

There’s a distinction that escapes me. All you Wal-Mart boycotters out there are now Wal-Mart Shop Elsewheres.

Ken V in Texas
Sunday, December 02 at 05:23 AM

It appears that you anti Walmart people are completely divorced from reality.

You continually talk about how Walmart is going down.  Then you go look at the newspapers and find out that Walmart is actually doing very well.

All WMW is doing is wasting millions of dollars of hard working union membe’s money.

John in OKC
Sunday, December 02 at 09:08 AM

John in OKC: That’s not quite correct, John. This is merely a legal separation,the completion of the divorce decree has yet to be finalized.

ddrb in
Sunday, December 02 at 10:29 AM

P.S.: And, if WMW has agreed to maing the alimony payments,what’s it to you? Are you a third party in the divorce?

ddrb in
Sunday, December 02 at 10:31 AM

tThat should have been “making”

ddrb in
Sunday, December 02 at 10:32 AM

..Walmart is actually doing very well.

By all means, John in OKC, give us some examples.

Go Missouri!

Ken V in Texas
Sunday, December 02 at 12:20 PM

In the last two days I have visited a Walmart, a Target and a K-Mart.

The Walmart was busy on Sunday morning.  The K-Mart was almost empty on both Saturday afternoon and Sunday morning.  The Target was not empty, but not nearly as busy as the Walmart on Saturday afternoon.

Don’t get me wrong, I like Target.  It is a neat store, but they are tending to be more a specialty store.  They do not even stock computers.  K-Mart is practically worthless.  Unfortunately, neither a Sam’s Club or Costco was available.

John in OKC
Sunday, December 02 at 01:32 PM

John in OKC: Have you ever been to or heard of Best Buy and Circuit City? If you know the particular model computer you are searching for, or of ANY items (electronics or otherwise) you may be seeking,you can go to BizRate.com, type in your preferred item-Presto,you’ll get a competetive price list for online merchants stocking your item.(No tax,and at times,free shipping,too!)

ddrb in
Sunday, December 02 at 01:49 PM

ddrb - NEWSFLASH - not ALL towns have a Best Buy/Circuit City within reach.

And many towns in rural America still do not have access to broadband internet, which kills the online shopping (ever tried dial-up in 2007?  Not a pretty sight).

Point is your suggestions, while they can work for some, they don’t work for all which is where Walmart comes-in.

bbrd in
Sunday, December 02 at 01:55 PM

John

Just for future reference, there are 5 Sam’s Clubs in the OKC area. 3 in OKC, 1 in Norman, and 1 (the first sam’s built) in Midwest City.

As for Costco unfortunately there are NONE in the state of Oklahoma as of yet. I do look forward to buying my membership as soon as they open their first store.

Big D in
Sunday, December 02 at 02:25 PM

bbrd:  Point is---That’s why it’s called a “suggestion- “I don’t know what is available to John. I would assume,perhaps wrongly,that since he’s capable of posting via internet here, wouldn’t that presuppose access to internet shopping sites and their avaiablity to him??

ddrb in
Sunday, December 02 at 02:36 PM

ddrd

I live in Midwest City and I can assure you that John has access to Best Buy’s/ Circuit Cities/ Sam’s/ High speed dial up/ cable T.V./ and Higher Education. I think that most of the state has indoor plumbing as well.

Big D in
Sunday, December 02 at 02:57 PM

Big D: Perhaps he has CHOSEN not to avail himself of some of these amenities???

ddrb in
Sunday, December 02 at 03:07 PM

Big D.  For your information, not all OKCs are Oklahoma City.

ddrb.  I looked in a Best Buy, K-Mart, Circuit City, Walmart, Office Max, Office Depot and Target for a computer.  I was surprised that Target did not stock computers.  I ended up buying in a Circuit City because in this particular case, they had the best price for exactly what I wanted.

John in OKC
Sunday, December 02 at 03:11 PM

John in OKC: You still might want to consider my suggestion. I know I’ve been able to save lots of $$ on shipping and especially tax, on big ticket items,by purchasing over the Internet!

ddrb in
Sunday, December 02 at 04:10 PM

Online shopping for electronics sucks. I recently had to buy and take back 3 or 4 Vista laptops before I found one that worked. I did this with existing big-box stores. This would have been a nightmare if I had to mail order the non-working computers and send them back over and over.

As for computers at Wal-Mart, they tend to cost 20% more than the ones at Best Buy. The Sams Club ones were even more expensive. Wal-Mart may provide the best deal much of the time, but not all of the time.

economic realist in e.g
Monday, December 03 at 06:26 AM

economic realist

I agree about the on-line shopping.

Your comments about computers costing 20% more at Walmart is wrong.  I looked at Toshibas, Acers, HP and Compaqs at Walmart, Sams Club, Best Buy and a number of other retailers.  They were the least expensive at Sam’s Club and Walmart.  Best Buy came in last.  I ended up buying at Circuit city because I like Toshiba and the only Toshiba’s that Walmart had were some of the more expensive models.  I found exactly what I wanted at Circuit City.

John in OKC
Monday, December 03 at 07:53 AM

John in OKC: I can understand one’s concerns when buying electronic equipment-there is always the issue of service after the sale. (But I bought a piece of electronic equpment at a retailer locally,and had to send it back to the manufacturer for repair.) I don’t know if this is standard procedure-I’m not too much of a techie. I can unequivically say that I saved thousands of $$$ buying some furniture,off the web...and delivered and set up in my home. Bizrate is the best site for price comparison shopping,IMHO.

ddrb in
Monday, December 03 at 10:03 AM

Wal-Mart really isn’t exacty doing well at all if you actually read the papers.Wal-mart is cost cutting new store opening ,stocks for wal-mart are going down ,alo one should realize that many people in several communities accrose the country are also banning Wal-Mart stores from opening.One also needs to remember that Wal-Mart also doesn’t list EVERYTHING bad about the company and while Wal-Mart is trying to publicize that they are infact a good company thier image of the Wal-Mart Corp is ruined everytime Lee Scott opens his mouth.Truth be told I for one don’t preffer Wal-Mart and I have begun boycotting the 4 we have in our city we don’t need Wal-Mart.Target,K-Mart,Shopko, and Home Depot is all we need.Fact is I live 2 blocks away from No-Frills,Kroger , and a Dollar Store so yes my money goes farther than goin to Wal-Mart. As for my clothing I just goto a retail outlet 5 miles away that’s better than going 20 miles to Wal-Mart.As for dial up I’ve had net zero never bothered me when I shopped on-line one only needs patience. For computer’s and computer part’s I buy those online along with my DVD’s so yes one has alot of opprotunities if one can utilize the power. And to that dumb Matthew think of it like this if Wal-mart is so wonderful why does it make its employees depend on federal aid and federal healthcare?Why does Wal-Mart depend on its employee’s to help out other employee’s in bad time’s? Reason being Wal-Mart is greedy and the companies over sight of this greed is being its down fall,Point proven Wal-Mart is slowing down opening stores because thier other stores are only 4-5 miles away from each other,3 of our Wal-Mart’s are 10 miles within each other so each store cuts into the other stores profit.Mass opening of stores has cost Wal-Mart more than they bargain for.We have 4 targets in this city however they are between 20-40 miles inbetween so there you go.Wal-Mart doesn’t list all of it’s problems to the media because it will humiliate them more than Lee Scott has but not by much.Wal-Mart care’s more about the public image than anything else but remember the old saying “Looks Are Decieving”

*Some Words may be misspelled but at least I have the bravery to say it*

Consumer Buyer in Midwest,USA
Monday, December 03 at 10:10 AM

Consumer buyer.  Apparently 75% of the population disagrees with you since they continue to happily shop at Walmart.

It doesn’t take much bravery to say anti Walmart things on this sire.  However, it does take some bravery to post pro Walmart things.  I was just blocked as “John”.

Johnboy in OKC
Monday, December 03 at 11:31 AM

John(boy) - absolutely amazing, but certainly not surprising.

As we pull back the curtain, we get a better look at the REAL WMW........

bbrd in
Monday, December 03 at 11:35 AM

...we get a better look at the REAL WMW........

Oh no! Not a conspiracy! Perhaps you were “blocked” because of the content of your posts, and not the ‘name’ you posted under?

Ken V in Texas
Monday, December 03 at 12:22 PM

Ken V - you mean..........

“The Walmart was busy on Sunday morning.  The K-Mart was almost empty on both Saturday afternoon and Sunday morning.  The Target was not empty, but not nearly as busy as the Walmart on Saturday afternoon.”

Yeah, I guess a statement like that could be considered Nick-level “controversial”, if I worked for WMW.

bbrd in
Monday, December 03 at 01:18 PM

Ken V - you mean..........

No. What I mean is that’s one store. This quote from Businessweek is more what I mean:

Wal-Mart disclosed a year and a half ago that same-store sales were rising 10 times, or 1,000%, faster at the 800 best-managed outlets than at the 800 worst-run ones. Equally shocking was its admission that 25% of its stores failed to meet minimum expectations of cleanliness, product availability, checkout times, and so on.

You know. The Big Picture!

Ken V in Texas
Monday, December 03 at 03:04 PM

consumer buddy how about all the people at the ufcw union grocery stores you shop at and love so dearly and all their folks on the govt food stamp and welfare doles? they have more workers on food stamps and welfare across the country because of poverty level wages and lack of quality hrs at their union grocery stores across the country than walmart does.got an answer on that pal?walmart workers are not on welfare or all this bs of govt assistance programs either.you are buying too much of the govt and ufcw union bs bud.pull your head out of the sand.

matthew vantress in gresham oregon
Tuesday, December 04 at 06:01 AM

funny consumer target takes business away from places you shop at we dont hear shit from you.walmart does the same thing you bitch?explain why you dont bitch about target doing the same thing?

matthew vantress in gresham oregon
Tuesday, December 04 at 06:04 AM

Ken V in Texas: One of the issues originally included on this thread referred to toxic toys. There is another astonishing tale of toxic toys,with a” twist"-an accusation of shoplifting and arrest of concerned citizen attempting to get a Dora the Explorer lamp taken off the WalMart shelves.(It was on recall list.) Go to Spprawl-Busters,type in newsflash-re: Des Arcs,Arkansas. It’s also on Huffington Post.I guess this proves the old adage that, “No good deed goes unpunished!”

ddrb in
Tuesday, December 04 at 11:46 PM

Ken V in Texas
Wednesday, December 05 at 02:55 AM

Commenting is not available in this content entry.

Comment Policy

WalmartWatch.com reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to remove or refuse to post blog comments.