“Greening” of Wal-Mart?
The Los Angeles Times examines Wal-Mart’s implementation of environmental improvements at its Aurora, CO test store...and visits the questions environmentalists are still asking about the company’s reluctance to address wages, benefits and health care as a part of the larger definition of sustainability.
Wind turbines, rows of tall windows, a 200-foot-long dimpled-metal wall and shiny rooftop solar panels are just hints of what’s to come.
Here, next to a busy freeway in suburban Denver, is tomorrow’s Wal-Mart today. And it’s getting a lot of attention.
For the last year, this experimental Wal-Mart Supercenter has been testing ways to be more environmentally sensitive in everything it does.
What works here won’t stay in Aurora. The world’s largest retailer wants ideas it can use in all of its more than 6,600 stores around the globe.
“The goal has never been to build demonstration stores,” said Andy Ruben, who heads the company’s environmental efforts. “The experimental stores are successful when the learnings get applied to all stores.”
Wal-Mart has been promoting its two experimental stores for years, and while we are hopeful that the company will build more environmentally sustainable stores to help meet its recent promises, we have yet to see actual results.
Likewise, prominent environmentalists are as yet unconvinced of Wal-Mart’s overall sustainability initiatives.
Carl Pope, executive director of the Sierra Club, declined to work with Wal-Mart on environmental matters because the company wouldn’t agree also to talk about labor, healthcare and other issues.
Nonetheless, Pope said that after examining Wal-Mart’s initiatives, he was convinced the company was making a sincere and significant commitment, even if he was skeptical that some goals could be reached.
“None of this is ‘greenstanding,’” said Pope, who also serves on Wal-Mart Watch’s board. “Their metrics are impressive; they’re not modest.
“They deserve the chance to show that their business model is compatible with high standards, not just low prices.”
Friends of the Earth, another environmental group that isn’t working with Wal-Mart, is more circumspect.
“There is a broader picture that needs to be considered,” said the group’s international director, David Waskow.
Part of the problem is that Wal-Mart donates money to politicians whom activists call anti-environment, the group said. It also questions whether the company is taking enough responsibility for its polluting suppliers.
- Click here to Visit Wal-Mart Watch’s Environmental page to track the company’s sustainability promises and join our environmental taskforce.
- Click here to visit our environmental blog for more information.
Posted by Laura Jack on Tuesday, November 14, 2006







COMMENTS
“Carl Pope, executive director of the Sierra Club, declined to work with Wal-Mart on environmental matters because the company wouldn’t agree also to talk about labor, healthcare and other issues”
Sierra Club Mission Statement (straight from their website)
1. Explore, enjoy and protect the wild places of the earth.
2. Practice and promote the responsible use of the earth’s ecosystems and resources.
3. Educate and enlist humanity to protect and restore the quality of the natural and human environment.
4. Use all lawful means to carry out these objectives.
So the Sierra Club is now interested in employee wages and healthcare. I’m so glad they have added those items to their charter. Oops, they didn’t… unless you’re talking about Walmart. What a joke Carl Pope is and he’s taking the stature of the Sierra Club and its supporters down with it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-Richard K
Richard K in
Tuesday, November 14 at 11:47 AM
““None of this is ‘greenstanding,’” said Pope, who also serves on Wal-Mart Watch’s board.”
Now I get it. Carl Pope is even more of a joke now.
-Richard K
Richard K in
Tuesday, November 14 at 11:48 AM
If you are NOT concerned about wages and healthcare you must rich.
Bob in Hazlet NJ
Tuesday, November 14 at 12:00 PM
I am not rich and I am concerned about wages and healthcare so that pretty much blows a hole in that theory. Now what again does the Sierra Club have to do with wages and healthcare or am I missing something?
-Richard K
Richard K in
Tuesday, November 14 at 01:19 PM
I wonder if someone is “concerned about wages and healthcare” because they may not make as much as a stockholder?
One will never know.
R E M E M B E R
J O N Q U I E R E
H O M E
O F
W A L M A R T
W O R K E R
A B U S E
Alex in Ontario, Canada
Tuesday, November 14 at 01:48 PM
help me out with this one please anybody. How does a government provide “affordable healthcare”? I don’t understand when the government assumed that responsibility. I want all people to do well too, as long as we have insurance who pay what doctors demand then we are removing the price information conveyed from the patients to the doctors. Health insurance distorts that price. The other aspect is this… Health insurance companies are in business to make a profit. If it wasn’t profitable they wouldn’t do it? RIGHT? So basically when we subscribe to health insurance we are paying the insurance companies more than they are paying for our health care? Right? When we do away with insurance and “affordable healthcare” as mandated by a government then we will begin to see the price of healthcare reflect the demand of those services. When the companies offer healthcare they are contributing to the distortion of that information. It is amazing to me that people pressure employers to provide health care.
bruce davis in conway, ar
Tuesday, November 14 at 02:44 PM
While Wal*Mart continues to proclaim how “Green” it is becoming, it has yet to address, the millions of tons of refuse it hauls away from its Supercenters a year.
Unless you are someone on the inside of the “box”, I guess you do not really know.
I still find it quite astounding how much these stores “compact” daily
into waste containers to be hauled away to god knows where?
Time was, Bud’s was a market for much of what Wal*Mart defines as “Claims”.
Bud’s was sort of the “yard sale” of Wal*Mart, and it absorbed much of that which is now routinely thrown away at stores.
Bud’s was at least some form of recycling.
There is no hard waste recycling present in Wal*Marts.
Fact is, unless you work inside a Wal*Mart, you will never know the extent of the immense waste-stream that exudes from any given Supercenter.
It is truly astounding.
At least 50% of all the objects you see in a Wal*Mart Supercenter, will at some point in time, represent themselves inside the local trash compactor.
The rest, sent to Wal*Mart “Return Centers“, well its junk too, so you make a guess on that disposition.
Even vendors routinely throw out unsold, non-perishable merchandise.
Everything but Planes, Trains, and Automobiles, goes to the landfills.
And folks, you would be TRULY AMAZED.
Wal*Mart “Green”? That is totally PR BS. Not worth the medium it is printed on unless its used toilet paper.
cazar in
Tuesday, November 14 at 08:52 PM
cazar i’m not sure because i have never been inside the box, but wouldn’t the same amount of waste be destributed by 100 stores that were each 1/100 of the size of wal-mart?
bruce davis in conway, ar
Tuesday, November 14 at 10:03 PM
Sweep the exhausted water area advertisement, the wow takes the lead.game
wowgold in e.g. Bentonville, AR
Wednesday, November 15 at 02:12 AM
Czar,
if you would keep up on the facts, you would see wal-mart is doing more then any of it’s competiton when it comes to dealing with the waste. Even the union stores don’t put in as much money to dealing with the waste..
“We believe that we should be able to conduct business in such a way that we generate no net waste. As a cost-conscious retailer we have always worked hard to reduce waste, although we once assumed a certain amount was an inevitable part of doing business. There are always creative alternatives.
We are moving toward our goal by recycling more materials, by refining our production and distribution systems so that we create less trash, and by selecting packaging that creates minimal waste.”
I know because I work as a hourly associate in one of their distribution centers and see this everyday. We get more and more cases of product/truck just from the decrease in packaging due to walmart pushing their vendors to better themselves..
Once banned from this site in PA
Wednesday, November 15 at 07:04 PM
Comment Policy
WalmartWatch.com reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to remove or refuse to post blog comments.